New York Times
WASHINGTON, Sept. 23 -- The 21-year-old Jordanian immigrant was in shackles when he was brought into the courtroom of Judge Michael B. Mukasey in Federal District Court in Manhattan.
It was Oct. 2, 2001, and the prisoner, Osama Awadallah, then a
college student in San Diego with no criminal record, was one of dozens
of Arab men detained around the country in the days after the Sept. 11
attacks as potential witnesses in the terrorism investigation.
Before
the hearing, Mr. Awadallah told his lawyer that he had been beaten in
the federal detention center in Manhattan, producing bruises that were
hidden beneath his orange prison jumpsuit. But when his lawyer told
this to Judge Mukasey, the judge seemed little concerned.
"As
far as the claim that he was beaten, I will tell you that he looks fine
to me," said Judge Mukasey, who was nominated by President Bush last
week to be his third attorney general and is now facing Senate
confirmation hearings. "You want to have him examined, you can make an
application. If you want to file a lawsuit, you can file a civil
lawsuit."
Even though Mr. Awadallah was not charged at the time
with any crime and had friends and family in San Diego who would vouch
that he had no terrorist ties, Judge Mukasey ordered that he be held
indefinitely, a ruling he made in the cases of several other so-called
material witnesses in the Sept. 11 investigations. A prison medical
examination later identified the bruises across his body.
I'll admit, I am concerned about this account. However, I also am
willing to give benefit of the doubt, considering just how soon after
9/11 this particular incident occurred. Hopefully, he will answer the
questions asked him at his hearing. If they are asked.
Update: Good point. Ah, okay,
very good point. (scroll down a bit)
Recent Comments